Topic- Petrol vs CNG vs EV Cars
Snapshot
Running cost: Petrol cars cost ₹6–₹8 per km, CNG cars ₹2–₹3 per km, EVs ₹1–₹1.5 per km.
Initial price: EVs are expensive upfront, while CNG is slightly costlier than petrol versions.
Maintenance: EVs have fewer moving parts, reducing service bills by 30–40%.
Break-even point: In 5 years, EVs can save over ₹3–₹4 lakh compared to petrol, while CNG saves around ₹1.5–₹2 lakh.
Best choice: Depends on driving habits, fuel prices, and charging/refuelling availability
Introduction
With rising fuel prices and growing concern for the environment, Indian car buyers are confused: Should I buy a Petrol, CNG, or EV car? While petrol cars remain the most common, CNG vehicles promise affordability, and EVs are being promoted as the future of mobility.
But the real question is: Which option actually saves you the most money in 5 years? Let’s break it down with costs, savings, and real-life factors.
1. Purchase Price Comparison
| Car Type | Average Price Range (India, 2025) |
|---|---|
| Petrol | ₹5–₹12 lakh |
| CNG | ₹6–₹13 lakh (₹80,000–₹1,00,000 more than petrol) |
| EV | ₹8–₹18 lakh (higher due to battery costs) |
👉 Petrol cars are cheapest to buy, but EVs come with incentives (FAME subsidy, state subsidies, road tax waivers).
2. Running Cost Per Kilometer
Petrol vs CNG vs EV
- Petrol: ₹105/litre (avg mileage 15 kmpl) → ₹7/km
- CNG: ₹80/kg (avg mileage 25 km/kg) → ₹3/km
- EV: ₹8/unit electricity (avg 6 km per unit) → ₹1.3/km
👉 EVs are cheapest to run daily, followed by CNG. Petrol is the most expensive.
While fuel and charging costs are key in car ownership, highway travel also brings toll charges into play. Did you know you can save big with a Toll Plaza Pass? Read our detailed guide
3. Maintenance Costs
Petrol vs CNG vs EV
- Petrol: Normal service, oil changes, filters → ₹6,000–₹8,000/year
- CNG: Slightly higher due to CNG kit checks → ₹7,000–₹9,000/year
- EV: No oil, fewer moving parts → ₹3,000–₹5,000/year
👉 Over 5 years, EV maintenance can be half of petrol/CNG.
4. 5-Year Cost of Ownership (10,000 km/year = 50,000 km)
| Car Type | Fuel/Energy Cost | Maintenance | Total in 5 Years |
|---|---|---|---|
| Petrol | ₹3.5 lakh | ₹40,000 | ₹3.9 lakh |
| CNG | ₹1.5 lakh | ₹45,000 | ₹1.95 lakh |
| EV | ₹65,000 | ₹25,000 | ₹90,000 |
👉 EV cars clearly save the most in running + maintenance over 5 years, followed by CNG.
5. Break-Even Analysis
- CNG vs Petrol: Extra purchase cost recovered in ~2 years if you drive >30 km/day.
- EV vs Petrol: Extra purchase cost recovered in ~4 years with subsidies + high running.
- EV vs CNG: EV becomes cheaper only if electricity is cheap and you drive >40 km/day.
6. Other Key Factors
- Infrastructure: Petrol pumps are everywhere, CNG stations limited to metros, EV charging is growing but still patchy.
- Convenience: Petrol wins on availability, EVs need planning for long trips.
- Resale value: Petrol cars hold value well, CNG moderate, EVs uncertain (battery degradation concerns).
- Eco-Impact: EVs produce no tailpipe emissions, CNG is cleaner than petrol, petrol is least eco-friendly.
7. Conclusion Petrol vs CNG vs EV
If your priority is low daily running cost and you live in a city with charging infrastructure, an EV will save you the most money in 5 years.
If charging is a challenge but you still want savings, CNG is the practical middle ground—cheaper than petrol but without EV’s range anxiety.
For convenience and nationwide availability, petrol cars remain hassle-free but are the costliest to own long-term.
👉 Final Verdict:
- Drive <20 km/day → Petrol is fine.
- Drive 20–40 km/day in a CNG-friendly city → Choose CNG.
- Drive >40 km/day with charging access → EV saves maximum money.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q1. Is EV really cheaper than petrol in India?
👉 Yes, EVs cost more upfront but save big in running and maintenance. Over 5 years, they can be 60–70% cheaper than petrol cars.
Q2. Which car type is best for city driving?
👉 EVs and CNG cars are best for cities due to lower running costs and eco-friendliness. Petrol cars are better only if you travel occasionally.
Q3. What about resale value of EVs?
👉 Resale is still evolving in India. Brands like Tata and MG offer battery warranties (8 years), which helps maintain resale confidence.
Q4. Is CNG safe for long drives?
👉 Yes, but CNG stations are limited outside metro areas, so long drives require planning.
Q5. How long does it take to recover extra EV cost?
👉 Around 4 years for average users, faster (2.5–3 years) if you drive more than 15,000 km annually.